So here’s the thing about aquascaping that nobody really talks about enough – tank dimensions will absolutely make or break your design, and I learned this the hard way after spending way too much money on plants that just didn’t work in my setup. When I first started this hobby about four years ago, I was completely focused on getting the “perfect” tank size, which I somehow convinced myself was this specific 6-gallon cube I’d seen on Instagram. But after getting deeper into the community and actually trying different layouts, I realized that tall versus shallow tanks are basically two completely different hobbies that happen to involve the same plants and fish.
I mean, seriously – the difference is wild once you start paying attention to it.
My first real lesson in this came when I was helping a friend set up her new 20-gallon high tank. This thing was gorgeous, like 24 inches tall but only 12 inches wide, and I walked into her apartment thinking I’d just apply everything I’d learned from my little cube tanks. Yeah, that didn’t work. At all. I spent three hours trying to create this iwagumi-style layout with rocks and carpeting plants, and it looked absolutely ridiculous – like someone had taken a normal aquascape and stretched it vertically in Photoshop. The proportions were completely wrong, the plants looked tiny and lost, and the whole thing just felt… empty? But not in a good minimalist way, more like “why is there so much water and so little happening” way.
That’s when I started researching tall tank aquascaping specifically, and discovered there’s this whole different approach that treats height as the main design element instead of fighting against it. Instead of trying to create horizontal layers like I was used to, successful tall tanks work more like underwater forests or cliff faces. You’re building vertically, creating these dramatic slopes that draw your eye upward, using the water column as negative space rather than trying to fill every inch with plants.
The plant selection for tall tanks threw me for a loop too. In my shallow setups, I was obsessed with carpeting plants – you know, Monte Carlo, baby tears, anything that would create that perfect lawn effect. But in a tall tank, carpeting plants just get lost unless you’re doing this massive foreground area, which usually doesn’t look proportional anyway. Instead, you want plants that actually use that vertical space. Vallisneria has become one of my favorites for tall tanks because it just shoots straight up toward the light, creating these natural curtain effects. Amazon swords work great too, especially the larger varieties that would overwhelm a shallow tank but look perfect when they have room to spread their leaves without hitting the top.
I’ve also gotten really into using Cryptocoryne species in different height zones within tall tanks. You can create these natural-looking transitions from low-growing crypts near the substrate up to medium-height varieties in the midground, then let your tall background plants take over from there. It creates this layered forest floor effect that’s impossible to achieve in a shallow tank where everything has to stay relatively low.
The hardscaping game is totally different too. In shallow tanks, I’m usually working with smaller pieces of driftwood and rocks, creating these intricate detailed scenes that you can see clearly from above. But tall tanks let you go big with the hardscape – I’m talking pieces of driftwood that extend from the substrate almost to the surface, creating these dramatic vertical elements that would look absurd in a 10-gallon long but are absolutely stunning in a tall setup.
One thing I didn’t expect was how much more challenging the maintenance would be. Trying to trim plants in the back of a 24-inch tall tank means I’m basically doing aquatic yoga, contorting myself to reach the bottom corners without disturbing everything else. I had to buy these ridiculously long aquascaping tools, and even then, major maintenance sessions turn into whole production numbers. My shallow tanks, I can just reach in and handle whatever needs doing. Simple.
But then there’s the flip side – shallow tanks, which I honestly didn’t appreciate enough when I first started. I always thought of them as the “beginner” option or the cheap alternative to “real” aquascapes. How wrong I was. Shallow tanks, especially something like a 20-gallon long that’s only 12 inches tall but 30 inches wide, open up completely different artistic possibilities that you just can’t achieve with depth.
The first time I set up a proper shallow tank layout, I finally understood what people meant when they talked about creating “vista” aquascapes. You’re not building vertically, you’re creating these expansive horizontal scenes that feel like looking across a natural landscape. I used Glossostigma elatinoides to create this rolling carpet effect, with gentle hills and valleys in the substrate creating natural-looking terrain. The whole thing looked like a miniature underwater prairie.
Shallow tanks are where carpeting plants really shine. I’ve had so much success with Eleocharis parvula creating these lush grass-like carpets that extend across the entire tank floor. The key is using the substrate topography to create interest – instead of a flat carpet, you can build rolling hills and valleys, create “streams” of sand cutting through the planted areas, even do these cool terraced effects if you’re feeling ambitious.
The open space in shallow tanks hits different too. In a tall tank, open water space just looks like… empty water. But in a shallow tank, open areas of sand or bare substrate become part of the composition. They’re like paths through a landscape, giving your eye places to rest and creating this sense of scale that makes the whole scene feel larger than it actually is.
Most popular
One of my favorite shallow tank techniques is creating these “forest floor” scenes using different textures of substrate and small pieces of driftwood arranged to look like fallen branches. I’ll use fine sand in some areas, slightly larger grain substrate in others, maybe some leaf litter if I’m going for a natural biotope look. The whole thing becomes this intricate miniature landscape that you can examine from different angles and always find new details.
The fish behavior is fascinating too, and totally different between tall and shallow setups. In my tall tanks, I love keeping fish that actually use the water column – angels that cruise up and down, or schools of tetras that create these vertical swimming patterns. Bottom dwellers kind of get lost in tall tanks unless you’ve got a really large footprint.
But shallow tanks are perfect for fish that naturally stay closer to the substrate or cruise horizontally. Corydoras are absolutely perfect in shallow setups because you can actually watch their behavior clearly – they’re not way down at the bottom of a deep tank where you need a flashlight to see them properly. Dwarf cichlids work great too because they can establish territories across the horizontal space without needing much vertical room.
The maintenance differences between tall and shallow are pretty significant too. Shallow tanks evaporate faster because of the larger surface area, so I’m topping off water way more frequently. But the trade-off is that everything’s accessible – I can reach every corner without special tools, trimming is straightforward, and cleaning the glass doesn’t require gymnastics.
Water parameter stability is weird in shallow tanks though. Less water volume means changes happen faster, which can be good or bad depending on your experience level. When I first started keeping shallow tanks, I had a few crashes because I wasn’t prepared for how quickly things could shift. Now I test more frequently and do smaller, more frequent water changes rather than big weekly ones.
The lighting situation is completely different between the two styles as well. Tall tanks need stronger lights to penetrate to the bottom, especially if you’re trying to grow carpeting plants 18+ inches below the surface. I learned this lesson expensively when I tried to use my standard nano tank LED on a friend’s tall setup and wondered why all the foreground plants were melting. Shallow tanks are much more forgiving with lighting, and you can get away with less expensive fixtures because the light doesn’t have to travel as far.
After working with both styles for a while now, I’ve realized they’re really addressing different aesthetic goals. Tall tanks are dramatic – they create these impressive vertical compositions that feel almost architectural. They’re statement pieces that draw attention and create focal points in a room. Shallow tanks are more contemplative, inviting you to look closer and discover details, creating these peaceful vista scenes that feel more like looking out a window than looking at an art installation.
I think the aquascaping community sometimes gets too caught up in debating which approach is “better,” when really they’re just different tools for different artistic visions. If you want to create something that feels like an underwater forest or mountain cliff, tall tanks give you the space to work with vertical elements and dramatic proportions. If you’re drawn to creating detailed landscape scenes with rolling topography and intricate planted areas, shallow tanks provide the canvas you need.
The cost considerations are worth mentioning too. Tall tanks often require more expensive lighting and longer tools for maintenance, but they use less substrate and you can create impressive scenes with fewer plants since you’re working more with negative space. Shallow tanks need more substrate and more plants to fill the space, but the equipment requirements are generally less demanding.
These days I find myself drawn to different tank styles depending on what I’m trying to achieve. My current project involves setting up a 40-gallon breeder – essentially a very shallow, wide tank – where I’m planning this ambitious stream-bed aquascape with different plant communities representing different zones along an imaginary waterway. But I’m also planning a tall tank setup eventually, probably something in the 29-gallon high range, where I want to try creating one of those dramatic cliff-face scenes with moss-covered rocks and plants cascading down from different levels.
The beautiful thing about this hobby is that there’s no wrong way to approach it, as long as you’re working with your tank’s proportions rather than against them. Whether you end up with a towering vertical composition or an expansive horizontal vista, the key is understanding what your particular tank dimensions do well and designing around those strengths rather than trying to force a vision that doesn’t fit the space.
Priya proves aquascaping doesn’t need deep pockets or big spaces. From her San Jose apartment, she experiments with thrifted tanks, easy plants, and clever hacks that keep the hobby affordable. Expect honest lessons, DIY tips, and a lot of shrimp in tiny jars.
